FREE ELECTRONIC LIBRARY - Abstracts, online materials

Pages:   || 2 | 3 |

«Remedies for Breach of Contract for Sale of Land Melbourne 2 October 2008* Speaker: John Arthur Barrister-at-Law Isaacs Chambers Melbourne, VIC ...»

-- [ Page 1 ] --

Remedies for

Breach of Contract

for Sale of Land


2 October 2008*

Speaker: John Arthur


Isaacs Chambers

Melbourne, VIC

Telephone: (03) 9225 8291

Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation

* revised March, 2011

Continuing Professional Development Seminars

Post Office Box 598, North Melbourne, VIC 3051

Telephone: (03) 9328 2688

Website: www.cpds.com.au

Table of Contents


The Different Meanings Of The Word “Rescission”

Rescission For Breach Of Condition Or Breach Of An Essential Term

Statutes Which Create Causes Of Action For Statutory Misrepresentation Or Misleading And Deceptive Conduct................ 9 Essential Pre-Requisites To The Exercise Of A Right To Rescind

Loss Of The Right To Rescind

The Consequences Of Rescission

Relief From Forfeiture In Favour Of A Purchaser Following A Valid Termination Of A Contract By A Vendor

Tanwar – Victorian Position

Other Remedies

Vendor’s Right To Damages

Purchaser’s Right To Damages

Specific Performance




1.1 Traditionally a distinction has been drawn between a right and a remedy. A right (in the sense of a cause of action) is viewed as a prerequisite to a remedy, thus it has been said for every right there is a remedy. The right is the primary, and the remedy is the secondary, obligation. There is also the distinction between remedies and procedure. Remedies are the ends which the administration of justice seeks to achieve and the procedure is the means for achieving those ends. Remedies may be classified as substitutional, specific or declaratory; in personam or in rem. Some are discretionary and others as of right. Remedies may have legal, equitable or statutory origins (see Principles of Remedies, Covell & Lupton, B/worths, 1995, pp. 2-4;

Remedies, Kercher & Noone, LBC, 1990, pp. 1-6).

Where a contract for the sale of land “goes off” by reason of one party‟s 1.2 default, the remedies which may be available to the innocent party will depend upon the right infringed and will include, rescission, termination, damages and/or specific performance, as well as analogous remedies under the Sale of Land Act 1986 (Vic) and the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth)* and Fair Trading Act 1999 (Vic)*. The party may need to invoke the remedy of rectification or in some circumstances, other ancillary equitable remedies, such as an injunction.

1.3 In this seminar, there will be a general discussion about the remedies available for breach of contract for sale of land, identifying the circumstances where they may become available and the pre-conditions to their grant.


1.4 Probably the most common, and arguably, the most important, remedy or right in the context of disputes surrounding contracts for the sale of land is that of rescission or termination. Depending upon the circumstances, the * see now, s. 18 Australian Consumer Law (which is Sched. 2 to the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth.)) remedy may be available to either vendor or purchaser. Often, the determination of which party has this right is a „watershed‟ issue, which will determine what other rights or remedies flow; which of the parties is innocent;

where the deposit should go and which party must pay damages. Often the question will simply be: by whose default did the contract “go off”?

1.5 As is discussed below, loss of bargain, or expectation, damages are only recoverable if the contract is at an end.

1.6 The failure to properly exercise the remedy, may result in the right being lost and may affect what other remedies are available. The right must be validly exercised – clearly, unequivocally and in proper form.

1.7 A claim to rescission is a right of action but is not itself a chose in action (and consequently cannot be assigned separately from the property affected by the transaction that is sought to be rescinded).

The different meanings of the word “rescission”:

In the law, the word “rescission” may be used in a number of different senses, 2.1


–  –  –

(largely drawn from the meanings of the term identified by Meagher Gummow & Lehane, Equity Doctrines & Remedies, 3rd Ed, para 2401-2405) It should be noted that the use of the word “rescission” in contexts other than 2.2 (c) above has been criticized on the basis that there is a clear distinction between rescission, or more correctly, discharge, or termination of future obligations on the one hand, and rescission ab initio on the other (eg. Photo Production Ltd v Securicor Transport Ltd [1980] AC 827 at 844; Halsbury’s Laws of Australia, para [110-9005]; Remedies, Kercher & Noone, 2nd Ed., LBC, pp. 257-258). In Victoria, the word “rescission” is used in the General Conditions in Table A of the Seventh Schedule of the Transfer of Land Act 1958 (Vic) (“Table A”) (see clauses 6 and 7) which has in the past been incorporated into most land contracts in Victoria in the senses referred to in (a) and (b) above and in the Sale of Land Act (eg. ss. 9AE(1), 27(8)(b), 32(5)). cf. the new General Conditions in the form of contract prescribed under the Estate Agents (Contracts) Regulations 2008 (“the new conditions of contract”).

[References hereinafter to the new conditions of contract will be simply “GC”].

Rescission for breach of condition or breach of an 3.1

essential term:

–  –  –

3.3.2 Transactions and dispositions (not just contracts) may be set aside ab initio (and not merely in futuro) in equity which have been improperly procured by equitable fraud, innocent misrepresentation, undue influence, breach of fiduciary duty or other unconscionable conduct.

(ibid, Meagher Gummow & Lehane at para 2403-4)

Statutes which give a right to rescind a contract:

3.4 3.4.1 In the context of contracts for the sale of land, the principal statute is the Sale of Land Act 1962 (Vic.)(“SLA”) which gives the purchaser many different rescission rights. The SLA also often specifies consequences of rescission.

–  –  –

(* see, Everest Project Developments Pty Ltd v Mendoza & Ors [2008] VSC 366; Clifford & Anor v Solid Investments Australia Pty Ltd [2009] VSC 223; affd on appeal Solid Investments Australia Pty Ltd v Clifford & Anor [2010] VSCA 59)

Acceptance of repudiation:

3.5 3.5.1 A right of rescission or termination will be available to the innocent party if the other party repudiates the contract. This will invariably involve a breach of condition as discussed in section 3.1 above.

–  –  –

4.1.1 A contravention of s. 52 Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth.)(“TPA”) may allow the Court to impose remedies very similar to rescission. This much litigated section extends to any conduct that is likely to mislead or deceive, as, for example, the making of negligent statements and false representations. Section 52 does not of itself create liability rather it establishes a norm of conduct and failure to observe that norm can be met by a range of remedies under the Act or under the general law. In the present context this includes, for contracts to be discharged and modified under s. 87 TPA where loss and damage has been, or is likely to be, suffered (viz. order declaring contract void or void ab initio (s. 87(2)(a), varying a contract (s. 87 (2)(b)) or refusing to enforce any provisions of a contract (s. 87(2)(ba))(see, generally, R. V Miller, Annotated Trade Practices Act, 33rd Ed., 2011, Thomson Reuters, Australia). If the party misled or deceived has suffered loss and damage as a result of the conduct, he or she may also recover damages under s. 82 Trade Practices Act. See now, s. 18 Australian Consumer Law (which is Sched. 2 to the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth.)) 4.1.2 In Victoria, the Fair Trading Act 1999 (Vic)(”FTA”) has enacted many of the provisions of the TPA. Comparable provisions to ss. 52 and 87 TPA can be found in ss. 9 and 158(2)(a), (b) and (c) FTA.

4.1.3 By way of example, a purchaser may seek to rescind a contract if in advertising land, a vendor or its agent has made representations misdescribing the property which induced the purchaser to enter into the contract to purchase it. The purchaser may seek to establish that the representations were misleading and deceptive in contravention of s. 52 TPA. If successful, and if avoided prior to completion, the Court would ordinarily order rescission, a refund of the deposit (eg Byers v Dorotea (1986) 69ALR 715) and interest. If after completion and the purchaser has retained the property, the damages would generally be based on the difference between the price paid for the property and its true value (Gates v City Mutual Life Association Society Ltd (1986) 160 CLR 1) and recoverable consequential losses.

Mutual abandonment/discharge by agreement:


–  –  –

4.2.2 The parties to a contract for the sale of land may also expressly agree to its discharge. The usual requirements for an enforceable and binding contract must be present, including consideration.

Essential pre-requisites to the exercise of a right to 5.1


–  –  –

5.3 Where rescission in equity is sought, the remedy is discretionary and the usual equitable defences apply, including laches and acquiescence.

Loss of the right to rescind:


Under the Common Law and in Equity:

6.1 The right to rescind will be lost if the party with such right affirms the contract (Sargent v ASL Developments Ltd (1974) 131 CLR 634), or if there is waiver or estoppel (Cth v Verwayen (1990) 170 CLR 394).

Delay in exercising the right may raise an estoppel, or be regarded as an election to affirm the contract or conduct precluding rescission (Principles of Equity, 2nd ed at pp 933-4).

6.2 A right to rescind for innocent misrepresentation may be lost after completion. Even though the rule in Seddon’s case has been disapproved, the High Court has recently cited it with apparent approval (Krakowski v Eurolynx Properties Ltd (1995) 183 CLR 563 at

585) and it has been applied in the context of land contracts in the past (eg Svanosio v McNamara (1956) 96 CLR 186). The rule does not apply if there has been fraud or even equitable fraud (Taylor v Johnson (1983) 151 CLR 422 at 431).

6.3 A vendor may be precluded from rescinding if it has engaged in unconscientious conduct in exercising his or her contractual right to terminate (Tanwar Enterprises Pty Ltd v Cauchi [2003] HCA 57;

(2003) 217 CLR 315).

–  –  –

6.4 Specific statutory provisions which confer rights of rescission will generally state when the right may be exercised and can also apparently be lost by affirmation (eg. Australian Horizons (Vic) Pty Ltd v Ryan Land Co Pty Ltd [1994] 2 VR 463)(cf. Everest Project

–  –  –

The consequences of rescission:


7.1 The consequences of rescission for the innocent party are that certain remedies may become available, the foremost of which is a right to damages (which is discussed in sections 11 – 13 below).

7.2 As has been noted (in paragraph 3.1.1), where a party elects to rescind a contract for breach of condition both parties are discharged from further performance but, as noted above, rights are not divested or discharged which have already been unconditionally acquired.

Where a contract is rescinded because of matters which affect its formation, the parties are restored, as far as possible, to their precontractual positions.

7.3 A purchaser who rescinds the contract upon a breach committed by the vendor will be entitled to recover his deposit and any other moneys paid by him under the contract and will also be entitled to recover damages for the breach (ibid Voumard at p. 448). Damages are dealt with in more detail below.

7.4 Where the vendor validly rescinds a contract for a failure by the purchaser to comply with a condition or for breach going to the root of the contract, the deposit is generally forfeited to the vendor, the vendor is relieved from further performance and he or she is entitled to sue the defaulting purchaser for damages.

7.5 Indeed, if a vendor validly rescinds a contract upon the failure of a purchaser to complete in accordance with an essential time stipulation, then, in the absence of fraud, accident or mistake or other conduct of the vendor which has in some significant respect caused or contributed to the breach of the essential time stipulation, the contract will be at an end and the purchaser will have no basis for seeking specific performance (ibid Tanwar). Tanwar is discussed in more detail below.

7.6 Where a purchaser rescinds the contract for misrepresentation or some other vitiating factor which affects its formation, the usual remedy is for orders for rescission and repayment of the deposit (eg.

Simons & Anor v Zartom Investments Pty Ltd [1975] 2NSWLR30).

Damages are not available for innocent misrepresentation. The misrepresentation must be negligent or fraudulent (or a „statutory misrepresentation‟ under s. 52 Trade Practices 1974 (Cth.) or s. 9 Fair Trading Act 1999 (Vic.)) to attract damages.

7.7 The consequences of rescission or discharge by agreement depend upon the terms of the agreement. The parties can agree what will take place upon the contract being discharged.

Relief from forfeiture in favour of a purchaser following a 8.

valid termination of a contract by a vendor: Tanwar

Enterprises Pty Ltd v Cauchi:

Pages:   || 2 | 3 |

Similar works:

«Personality Styles and Careers THE PERFECT CAREER MATCHES WHO YOU ARE People work harder and achieve better results when they’re doing work that gives them a great deal of satisfaction. If you don’t find the work enjoyable and rewarding you will not perform to the best of your ability. It’s important therefore to find out what motivates you, what drives you and what you are best suited to do, based on who you are. Certain people do better at some jobs than others. The trick is to discover...»

«David Kyle: Minor Surgery Chapter 4: Ear, Nose and Throat The Ear Trauma Wounds of the Pinna Wounds of the ear, varying from a small nick to almost complete avulsion, occur as a result of road accidents, usually in conjunction with other head or facial injuries. After routine cleansing, débridement is kept to the minimum compatible with viability and every effort is made to restore the normal anatomy of the part. There are enough landmarks on the ear to make accurate apposition of the cut...»

«Ali Agha (full name: Ali-akbar Agha-mohammadi) – CV (as of Sep 2013) Parasol Lab, Department of Computer Science and Engineering, Dynamics and Control Lab, Department of Aerospace Engineering, Texas A&M University, College Station, TX 77843-3112 Email address: aliagha@tamu.edu Homepage: https://parasol.tamu.edu/people/ali Education Dept. of Computer Science and Engineering, Texas A&M University PhD in Computer Engineering, 2013 Thesis: Sampling-based State Estimation and Stochastic Control...»

«1 Judging work: The concept of ‘work’ in Hannah Arendt’s ‘The Human Condition’ Abstract: Work for Arendt marks the ‘worldliness’ of human life. It is the artificial world of fabrication and reification of things through the tools of what Arendt calls as ‘homo faber’. This material human world created by artists, craftsmen, and workers of all kinds adds permanence to human life which is otherwise transitory. What then should be the parameters of judging products of work? Unlike...»

«Missionaries of Jesus District of the Americas August 23, 2014 The members of the Missionaries of Jesus-Americas: (L-R) Fr. Aris Villanueva, Fr. Manuel Gacad, Fr. Rey Tejico, Fr. Melanio Viuya, Francisca Muxtay, Fr. Michael Montoya, Fr. Efren “Wren” Reyes (General Council Member), Fr. Joseph Guerrero and Fr. Enrique Ymson. A Fundraising Event for the Missionaries of Jesus We thank you for helping us discover and uncover the Face of Jesus hidden in the faces of our poor brothers and sisters...»

«Approved by the Regents November 20, 2014 OCTOBER MEETING, 2014 The University of Michigan Flint Campus October 16, 2014 The regents met at 3:00 p.m. in the Riverfront Center, UM-Flint Campus. Present were President Schlissel and Regents Bernstein, Darlow, Diggs, Ilitch, Newman, and White. Also present were Vice President and Secretary Churchill, Vice President Harper, Interim Vice President Hu, Interim Executive Vice President Johns, Chancellor Little, Vice President Lynch, Vice President May,...»

«NOT RECOMMENDED FOR PUBLICATION File Name: 14a0766n.06 No. 13–1824 UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FILED FOR THE SIXTH CIRCUIT Oct 07, 2014 DEBORAH S. HUNT, Clerk UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, ) ) Plaintiff – Appellee, ) ON APPEAL FROM THE UNITED ) STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR v. ) THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF ) MICHIGAN JERON GASKIN, ) ) Defendant – Appellant. ) BEFORE: DAUGHTREY, McKEAGUE, and WHITE, Circuit Judges. HELENE N. WHITE, Circuit Judge. Jeron Gaskin was convicted of conspiracy to possess...»

«FEATURED REPRINT The Cycle Completed: Mothers and Children Nancy CHODOROW Families create children gendered, heterosexual, and ready to marry. But families organized around women’s mothering and male dominance create incompatibilities in women’s and men’s relational needs. In particular, relationships to men are unlikely to provide for women satisfaction of the relational needs that their mothering by women and the social organization of gender have produced. The less men participate in...»

«Dynamic Bargaining over Redistribution in Legislatures Facundo Piguillem and Alessandro Riboni∗ February 15, 2011. Abstract This paper analyzes the standard Neoclassical growth model where agents are heterogeneous in their initial wealth. Wealth can be taxed in order to finance equal lump-sum transfers. We consider a representative democracy where elected officials select the current capital tax by playing a legislative bargaining game. Specifically, one member of the legislature makes a...»

«Scottish Journal of Arts, Social Sciences and Scientific Studies ISSN 2047-1278 http://scottishjournal.co.uk SCOTTISH JOURNAL OF ARTS, SOCIAL SCIENCES AND SCIENTIFIC STUDIES VOLUME 7, ISSUE II JANUARY, 2013 Articles A Case Study of IT Outsourcing in Southeast Asia 2 Supaporn Kupimai 2 Terawat Piboongungon, Ph.D 2 Effects of Organization Performance on Share Price: an Empirical Study of the Top Performing Manufacturing Companies Listed on Nigeria Stock Exchange 15 Fagbemi Ayodele Omoyiola Ph. D...»

«FOREWORD The purpose of this handbook is to provide information that will help acquaint you with some of the basic information about the Hattiesburg Public School District, your rights and responsibilities as an employee, and to provide you with a brief overview of the wide array of policies, benefits, and services that relate to your employment. Board Policies are made available for your review on the District’s website at www.hattiesburgpsd.com and at the Central Administrative Office. The...»

«Riika Halme. 2004. A tonal grammar of Kwanyama. Namibian African Studies, Vol. 8. Köln: Rüdiger Köppe Verlag, i-xii + 299 pp. Reviewed by Thera Crane & Larry M. Hyman, Department of Linguistics, 1203 Dwinelle, University of California, Berkeley CA 94720-2650. Riika Halme’s monograph, A tonal grammar of Kwanyama, is an important contribution to the study of the Oshiwambo (Guthrie R.20) group of Bantu languages spoken in Angola and Namibia. Since tonal information on the languages of this...»

<<  HOME   |    CONTACTS
2017 www.abstract.dislib.info - Abstracts, online materials

Materials of this site are available for review, all rights belong to their respective owners.
If you do not agree with the fact that your material is placed on this site, please, email us, we will within 1-2 business days delete him.